Bitcoin Mining Labby Coinovo

Mining Lab · Coinovo Academy · Tokenomics, taken apart

Tokenomics, taken apart

Bitcoin as the worked example, projects under test

In depth 18 min 8 cards 18 questions

Objectives

What tokenomics actually is

Tokenomics is the question of how many units of a currency exist, how they come into circulation, what they are needed for and how they disappear again. Four questions, nothing more. Most projects answer the first two at length and the last two not at all, and that is exactly where they fail.

The best worked example is Bitcoin: its rules are open in the code, have run since 2009 and anyone can recalculate them. Once you have understood them, you read every other paper with different eyes.

Supply, issuance, use, outflow. Lose one and the model tips over.

Full explanation

Why the fourth question is the hardest

Issuing new units is easy: you write a number into an account. Taking them out of circulation again is hard, because someone has to give something up voluntarily.

Where no outflow is built in, the circulating supply keeps growing. If demand does not grow at least as fast at the same time, the value per unit falls. That is not an opinion about the market but arithmetic: the same demand spread across more units means less per unit.

So the most honest question to ask of any project is not "how many are there?" but "what makes them fewer again?". If the answer is "sales to new buyers", that is not an outflow but a hand-over.

The three kinds of use

A token can be three things, and most are only one of them. Means of payment: you need it to pay for something in the system. Claim: it entitles you to a share of something. Vote: it lets you take part in decisions.

The distinction is more than hair-splitting. A token that grants a claim on profits can, depending on its design, be a security in Europe, with all the duties that come with it. A token used to pay for equipment in a game usually is not. Anyone assessing a project therefore asks first: what exactly does this token promise me?

Total supply and its pots

Every project should be able to say how many units can exist at most and who they are meant for. An invented example: the project Pebble has one billion units. Forty per cent go to the community, twenty to the team, fifteen to investors, twenty-five to a reserve. Exactly one hundred per cent together.

That is not a given: with many projects the stated shares add up to more than one hundred per cent, or an unnamed remainder is left over. Bitcoin is the exception in the other direction: there are no pots and no allocation. Every coin comes from mining, including those of the very first participants.

The shares have to add up exactly. An unnamed remainder is a question.

Full explanation

Why a pot for gifts is necessary

Every system that gives newcomers something is creating it out of nothing. That is fine as long as the amount is limited and assigned to a pot. It becomes a problem when the gifts hang on no pot at all: then the supply grows with every new account, with no limit anywhere.

Work it through for Pebble. The reserve holds 250 million units. Each new account receives 100 as a welcome. 250,000,000 divided by 100 is 2.5 million accounts, and then the reserve is empty from welcomes alone.

Such a number is honest even if it is not pretty: it says how many users the model is built for. If you read "infinitely scalable" about a project and at the same time see fixed gifts per account, you have found a contradiction.

Who else holds shares

Team and investors usually do not receive their shares at once but according to a schedule called an unlock. Until the date the units are locked, afterwards they may be sold.

For everyone else this schedule is one of the most important numbers of all. If many units unlock on one day, there is often no buyer of the same size on the other side. A project that does not state its unlock schedule is hiding the day on which the market changes the most.

Bitcoin: issuance halves

With Bitcoin, new coins arise only as the block reward. At the start it was 50 per block, and every 210,000 blocks the amount halves: 25, 12.5, 6.25, 3.125 and so on. At about 144 blocks a day that is roughly every four years.

The cap of 21 million is therefore not an extra law but the result of the halving rule: the sum of ever smaller amounts converges on a fixed value. 210,000 times 50 times 2 gives 21 million.

The cap follows from the issuance rule, not the other way round.

Full explanation

The calculation in detail

The first stage brings 210,000 times 50, that is 10.5 million bitcoin. The second half of that, 5.25 million, the third 2.625 million. Each stage brings half as much as the one before. Such a series is called geometric, and its sum is twice the first term: 2 times 10.5 million equals 21 million.

Precisely, it is 20,999,999.9769 bitcoin. The reason is rounding: the reward is counted in whole satoshi, and at every halving the remainder below one satoshi drops away. The odd number is not a mistake but the rounding.

Continuous instead of in steps

Some projects do not halve in steps but let the amount fall a little every day, so that it has halved after T days. Then the total supply is the daily amount at the start times T divided by the natural logarithm of 2, roughly 0.6931.

An invented example: 10,000 units on day one, halving every 1,000 days. 10,000 times 1,000 divided by 0.6931 gives about 14.4 million. If you want to check the cap of a project, you can recalculate it like this in a minute.

What you take away for other projects

If a project states a fixed cap AND a fixed daily payout, the two have to fit together. If they do not, there are only two possibilities: either the payout stops abruptly at some point, and on that day the business model of everyone living off it collapses. Or the cap is raised later, and then it never was one.

The check takes a minute: daily amount times 365 times the planned years. If that is more than the cap, something is wrong. If it is very much less, most of the supply will never be paid out; then the question belongs on the table of who holds the rest.

Why more participants do not mean more coins

What a Bitcoin miner takes in per day is not fixed. It is their share of the total computing power times what the network pays out in a day. When new machines join, the difficulty rises and it stays at about 144 blocks a day.

The consequence: more participants do not create more coins, they split the same amount among more heads. That is the difference between a model that still holds with millions of users and one that collapses under them.

Fixed issuance, growing denominator. That is the whole safeguard.

Full explanation

Worked through

At 3.125 bitcoin per block and 144 blocks a day, 450 new bitcoin arise daily, plus the fees. All the miners in the world share these 450, no matter how many there are.

If the network's computing power doubles, it stays at 450. Each single machine then gets only half. The total stays tight, but there is less for the individual the more people take part. Both are the same calculation seen from two sides.

The thinking error many fall for

Anyone who reads "you earn X coins a day" and takes it as a fixed promise is calculating wrongly. In every shared system X is a share, not a fixed quantity. The same machine brings less tomorrow than today if others join overnight.

The question to ask instead is: how big is my share of the whole, and how fast is the whole growing? Only that gives a calculation that still holds in six months.

Use and outflow

Use answers why anyone wants the token at all. With Bitcoin it is paying and storing value without a middleman. With Ethereum every transaction needs gas, which is paid in ether.

Outflow is the half most projects leave out. Ethereum has had one built in since 2021: the base fee of every transaction is burned, that is removed from the supply for good. It does not go to another account, it is gone.

Burned means burned: not redistributed, but out of the supply.

Full explanation

Burning is not magic

Whether the circulating supply grows or shrinks is a simple calculation: newly issued minus burned. With Ethereum the result depends on how busy the network is. When many transactions are under way, a lot is burned and the supply can fall. When little is going on, issuance outweighs it.

Burning is therefore not a gift to holders but a consequence of use. A project that promises burning but has no use is promising a number without a basis.

A hand-over is not an outflow

Some projects call it outflow when units flow back to an account of the operator. That is not burning but a rebooking: the units are still there and can be spent again at any time.

Bitcoin, by the way, has an involuntary outflow: coins whose keys are lost lie still forever. Nobody knows exactly how many there are, because a coin that has not moved for a long time may just as well be well stored.

Where payouts come from

Many projects promise rewards. The most important question is then not how much but from where. There are exactly four honest answers: advertising income, sales revenue, commissions from partners, or income from another business.

Every other answer, whether "from growth", "from the token" or "from the ecosystem", means that payouts come from deposits. That works exactly as long as more newcomers arrive than old hands want to cash out.

No income, no payout. The order is not negotiable.

Full explanation

Why a budget has to hang on income

A serious reward system can never pay out more than came in beforehand. Whether that is ten, twenty or forty per cent of income is a decision. What matters is that the reference figure is real money that was actually received.

Without that link, the system pays the old hands from the money of the newcomers. There is a name for that, and no chart, however pretty, changes it.

The test question in everyday life

For any app promising "earn real money", ask where it comes from. If it is not written anywhere, ask. If you get no answer, that is the answer.

With Bitcoin the source is open: newly created coins under a fixed rule plus the fees paid by users. Nobody promises a yield there, and precisely that keeps the calculation honest.

Game currency, token or security

Not every digital unit is a cryptocurrency. A game currency lives in a database, cannot be traded between users and has no rate. A token on a blockchain can be transferred freely. And a token that grants a claim on profits can legally be a security.

Knowing which of the three drawers something belongs in tells you which rules apply and which promises are even allowed.

Sort out the drawer first, then read the promises.

Full explanation

Why this distinction is more than caution

An app that makes a game currency look like a cryptocurrency quickly moves, in Europe, into an area that needs a licence. As soon as a token is tradable, has a rate or grants a claim on a yield, rules apply that do not apply to game currencies.

That is not small print but a design decision with consequences. Anyone building or buying something should know this line before crossing it.

A price is not a rate

A price is set by a seller: it says at what amount they sell something. A rate emerges from the supply and demand of many participants in a market.

Projects that blur this difference are selling a price promise they cannot keep. If a value in euros is shown somewhere, it is worth asking: can I also sell at that value, and to whom?

The checklist you take with you

Six questions, and you can place any project in ten minutes. First: is there a cap, and does issuance fit it? Second: who holds which share, and do the shares add up to one hundred per cent? Third: what is the token really needed for? Fourth: what makes it disappear again? Fifth: where does the money for payouts come from? Sixth: what happens if no new users arrive tomorrow?

The sixth is the hardest. A model that only works with growth is not a model but a bet.

Question six answers most projects by itself.

Full explanation

How to find the answers

The figures are almost always somewhere: in the project's paper, in the contracts on the chain, or in one of the public explorers. What is missing is rarely missing by accident.

A practical handle: look for the distribution of shares and add it up. If it comes to more than one hundred per cent or leaves an unnamed remainder, stop there. Then look for the word unlock, that is when the shares of founders and investors become movable. If that date is shortly after launch, the rest of the reading is usually unnecessary.

The test on an invented example

A project writes: total supply 10 billion. Of that, 40 per cent to the community, 20 to the team, 15 to investors, 15 to the foundation, 20 to the ecosystem. 5 million paid out per day, permanently.

First: 40 + 20 + 15 + 15 + 20 is 110 per cent. You could stop here.

Second: 5 million a day is 1.825 billion a year. The 4 billion for the community would be spent after two and a quarter years, and then the payout would have to end or come from another pot. Neither is stated anywhere.

Third: team and investors together hold 35 per cent. If their unlock falls due after one year, 3.5 billion units face a market that has absorbed a good 1.8 billion by then.

Three numbers, two minutes, and the question is answered. That is how you read a paper.

Glossary

Tokenomics
Supply, issuance, use and outflow of a currency.
Emission
The rate at which new units arise.
Burn
Final removal from the circulating supply.
Circulating supply
What is actually in hands, not what could exist.
Unlock
The point at which held shares become movable.
Issue price
A price set by the seller; not a rate from supply and demand.

Further reading

This module comes with 18 explained questions. They live in the app, along with your progress and the credit for finishing.
The Coinovo appA reason to come back every dayTasks, shifts and the daily hunt, plus an account that shows what has added up.Daily tasksYour own accountCosts nothingStart now

More modules

What Bitcoin isMoney without a middlemanHow mining worksGuessing until it fitsHashrateHow much guessing goes onThe difficultyWhy the rhythm holdsThe halvingThe reward shrinksWallets and keysWhat you never hand overFeesYou pay for spaceMining poolsTogether instead of aloneSpotting fraudThe same tricks every timeEthereum and smart contractsA shared computer with a fee meterProof of stake and stakingCollateral instead of electricityStablecoinsStable as long as the backing holdsDeFi: financial services made of codeSwap, borrow, lend without a bankThe Lightning NetworkBitcoin instantly, with conditionsSpotting and stopping scamsCheck first, then signAI and cryptoA tool, not an oracleInvesting with a planRules instead of gut feelingRunning mining as a businessWhat a machine really costsSelf-custody in practiceFrom the first key to inheritanceTax and bookkeepingWhat the tax office wants to seeHow the network really worksNodes, mempool, forksRisk and position sizeHow not to lose everything