Mining Lab · Coinovo Academy · Stablecoins
Stable as long as the backing holds
A stablecoin is meant to hold a fixed value, usually one US dollar or one euro. That lets you pay or park money on a blockchain without carrying the price risk of ETH or bitcoin. But stable is a goal, not a law of nature. What matters is what stands behind the token and whether you can actually redeem it.
A stablecoin is as stable as whatever backs it.
In the most common design an issuer accepts euros or dollars and issues tokens in return. It holds the money as a reserve, for example as bank deposits or in short-term government bonds. Like a cloakroom ticket, the token is worth what hangs in the cloakroom. The risks lie with the issuer, with the banks holding the reserve, and in the fact that the issuer can freeze individual addresses.
Holding the token means trusting the issuer.
Not every reserve is the same. Cash in a bank account is available immediately, but only as safe as the bank. Short-term government bonds count as very safe and can be sold quickly. Longer-dated bonds, corporate loans or other crypto assets earn more interest but also carry more risk, especially when many holders want to redeem at the same time.
The interest on the reserve is earned by the issuer, not by the token holder. That is its business model. For you it means: you carry a risk for which you receive no interest. All the more important that the reserve is complete and invested cautiously.
March 2023 showed how quickly a reserve can become a problem. A large dollar-backed stablecoin briefly fell well below one dollar after it became known that part of its reserve was held at a US bank that had just collapsed. Only once it was clear that the deposits at that bank would be protected did the price recover.
Many issuers regularly publish an attestation. In it an accounting firm confirms that reserves of a certain size existed on a certain reporting date. That is better than nothing, but it says nothing about the next day and usually little about how good the internal controls are.
A full audit goes further: it looks at a whole period, the bookkeeping and the controls. Anyone reading a report should check four things: the date, who did the review, what the reserve consists of and whether it is at least as large as the number of tokens issued.
Missing information is information too. If reports come out late, if the reviewing firm changes often or if the composition of the reserve stays vague, that is a warning sign. An issuer that is well backed has every reason to show it clearly.
In this design you deposit crypto assets such as ETH in a smart contract and mint stablecoins against them, but fewer than the collateral is worth. This is called overcollateralisation. An example: deposit 1,500 euros in ETH, receive 1,000 stablecoins. If the collateral falls below a set threshold, in this example 120 percent of the debt, it is sold automatically: the liquidation. There is no bank risk, but there is price, code and oracle risk.
Overcollateralisation is the buffer against volatile collateral.
Algorithmic stablecoins try to hold their value through rules that create and destroy tokens, usually together with a sister token. A real reserve does not exist or only in part. This works as long as people believe the sister token has value. If they stop, a downward spiral can start that feeds on itself.
The basic idea is a swap the protocol offers at any time: for one stablecoin you get one dollar worth of sister token, and the other way round. If the stablecoin trades below one dollar, traders buy it cheaply, swap it for one dollar worth of sister token and pocket the difference. The stablecoin is destroyed in the process, the supply shrinks and the price rises.
If it trades above one dollar, the reverse happens: traders swap sister token into new stablecoins and sell them. In this way the price is meant to keep returning to one dollar without a single dollar sitting in a reserve anywhere.
The weakness lies in the word worth. The dollar you receive in the swap is not a dollar but newly created sister token. If many want to leave at once, more and more of it is created, its price falls, and every further swap needs even more. The mechanism meant to stabilise becomes an accelerant.
That is exactly what happened in May 2022 to TerraUSD, then the largest algorithmic stablecoin. After heavy outflows it lost its peg to the dollar. Within a few days the sister token fell almost to zero, and value in the billions had vanished. Many holders had considered the stablecoin a safe place for their savings.
A large part of the demand came from an application that paid a strikingly high and steady return on the stablecoin. Where that return was supposed to come from in the long run was never convincingly explained. When doubts arose, many wanted out at the same time, and the spiral described in the previous section set in.
Two lessons follow. A token is not stable because of its name, but only if something stands behind it that can be redeemed even in a rush. And a return higher than anything the backing can produce demands the question of where it comes from. The case also shaped regulation in Europe.
A depeg happens when the price of a stablecoin moves clearly away from its target value. Causes include doubts about the reserve, halted redemptions, falling collateral or a mass exit. It resembles a run on a bank: whoever redeems first gets the full value. Normally traders pull the price back by buying cheaply and redeeming at face value, but only as long as redemption is possible.
The peg holds exactly as long as redemption is possible and credible.
Since 30 June 2024 the MiCA rules for stablecoins apply in the EU. E-money tokens refer to a single official currency, such as the euro. Only credit institutions and e-money institutions may issue them, and holders have the right to redeem at face value at any time, free of charge. Asset-referenced tokens refer to something else or to a mix, for example a basket of currencies and gold. For both types the issuer may not pay interest to holders.
Before MiCA practically anyone could call a token a stablecoin. Now anyone offering such a token to the public in the EU needs an authorisation, has to publish a whitepaper with prescribed information and is subject to supervision. The reserve has to be kept separate from the issuer's own assets and invested cautiously.
For e-money tokens the right of redemption is the core: a euro token has to be taken back for one euro at any time, free of charge. Asset-referenced tokens also come with a right of redemption, based on the market value of the assets the token refers to. Particularly large tokens face stricter duties, and the European Banking Authority takes on additional supervision.
The interest ban looks unfriendly to customers at first glance. Its purpose, however, is to stop stablecoins from being used like savings accounts without meeting the protection rules for savings accounts. Anyone offered interest on a stablecoin should therefore ask exactly who pays it and where it comes from.
A right of redemption is a claim against the issuer, not a state guarantee. Unlike deposits in a bank account, e-money tokens are not covered by deposit insurance. If the issuer fails, everything depends on whether the separately held reserve really is complete.
MiCA governs who may offer such tokens and bring them to trading in the EU. A token from another country without authorisation may not be offered to the public in the EU, but anyone already holding it in their own wallet is not affected by that. And a token that tries to hold its value purely through an algorithm, without referring to any asset, does not get the protection of these categories.
Finally, no classification guarantees a market price. Even an authorised token can briefly trade below face value on an exchange, in a panic for instance. Regulation improves the chances that it returns, but it does not abolish the risk.
Four questions are enough for a first impression. Who issues the token, and where is the issuer authorised? What does the reserve consist of, and how recent is the last report? Who may redeem, and what does it cost? Can the issuer freeze balances? Whoever cannot find an answer to one of these questions does not know their risk.
Who issues, backed by what, who redeems, who can freeze.